If you want paper cat litter that clumps, note that the paper options here are non-clumping pellets. Fresh News and Small Pet Select offer recycled-paper choices for absorbency and odor control, while Tuft & Paw is a clumping alternative made from tofu, not paper. The Fresh News 25-pound bag suits households buying in larger quantities; its 12-pound bag is a smaller option. The multi-cat formula is another paper choice, and Small Pet Select is for buyers seeking paper pellets without baking soda.
| Product | Type | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Fresh News Original, 12 Pound | Non-clumping recycled paper | Smaller quantities |
| Fresh News Original, 25 Pound | Non-clumping recycled paper | Larger quantities |
| Fresh News Multi-Cat | Non-clumping recycled paper | Multi-cat households |
| Tuft & Paw Really Great | Clumping tofu | Shoppers prioritizing clumping |
| Small Pet Select | Non-clumping recycled paper | Paper litter without baking soda |
Fresh News Original Paper, 12 Pound
Best for: Cat owners who want recycled-paper pellets in a smaller bag. This unscented, non-clumping litter is made with 100% post-consumer paper. The manufacturer says its pellets provide nearly three times the absorbency of clay, retain their form when wet, and use baking soda to help neutralize odors.
It is a good fit for buyers who prefer paper pellets and want the listed odor-control ingredient. The product is also described as biodegradable when composted. Limitation: It does not form scoopable clumps, so choose another product if clump removal is a priority.
Fresh News Original Paper, 25 Pound
Best for: Households that want the same Fresh News Original formula in a larger bag. Its listed features include 100% post-consumer recycled paper, unscented pellets, baking soda for odor control, and moisture absorption. The manufacturer also states that the pellets are soft, dust-free, and retain their form when wet.
Choose this size if you prefer to stock more of the same non-clumping formula rather than buy the smaller bag. Its recycled-paper material may appeal to shoppers looking for a paper-based option. Limitation: Like the 12-pound version, it is non-clumping and is not a match for buyers who specifically require paper litter that forms clumps.
Fresh News Multi-Cat Paper Pellets
Best for: Buyers seeking a paper-pellet formula labeled for multi-cat use. It is made with 100% post-consumer recycled paper, and its features include fast-absorbing pellets, baking soda for odor control, and moisture-locking granules. The manufacturer says the pellets retain their form when wet and are designed for low tracking.
This option was selected for its multi-cat positioning and combined absorption and odor-control features. Limitation: It is non-clumping, so it will not provide the distinct clumps some owners expect when scooping. The listing does not specify a different removal method or a clumping version.
Tuft & Paw Really Great Tofu Litter
Best for: Shoppers who prioritize clumping but are willing to choose a non-paper material. This tofu litter is made from soybean byproduct and is described as fast-clumping, dust-free, and low-tracking. The listing says its pellets break down quickly in water and describes the product as flushable.
It is included as a clumping alternative because the paper options in this selection do not clump. Choose it if clump formation matters more than having paper litter. Limitation: It is tofu litter, not paper litter, so it does not meet a strict requirement for a paper-based product. Follow local plumbing and disposal guidance before flushing litter.
Small Pet Select Recycled Paper Litter
Best for: Buyers who want recycled paper pellets with odor control but no baking soda. The product is described as non-toxic, non-clumping, and made in the USA. Its features include moisture-locking pellets, an all-natural odor blocker, and absorption of up to three times more than clay. The listing says pellets gently expand for spot-scooping.
This product was selected for shoppers comparing paper litters with different odor-control ingredients. Choose it if avoiding added baking soda is important to your selection. Limitation: It does not clump, and its odor-control approach differs from the Fresh News formulas that list baking soda.
Buying Guide: How to Choose Paper Cat Litter
Does paper cat litter clump?
The paper products in this selection are explicitly non-clumping. Their pellets absorb moisture but retain their form rather than forming scoopable clumps. If you require clumping, the listed Tuft & Paw product is a tofu alternative, not a paper litter.
Which pellet formula fits your household?
Compare the product’s stated use and features rather than assuming every pellet formula works the same way. Fresh News offers an Original formula in two bag sizes and a Multi-Cat version. Small Pet Select offers a paper option with an odor blocker and no baking soda. The available descriptions do not provide a direct, tested comparison of odor performance.
What should you compare for odor control and cleanup?
Look at the listed odor-control ingredients, absorbency claims, and pellet behavior. Fresh News lists baking soda; Small Pet Select says it uses an odor blocker without baking soda. Non-clumping products do not give the same clump-based scooping method as clumping litter, so consider whether that difference suits your routine.
Does recycled paper matter to your choice?
Fresh News and Small Pet Select describe their products as made with recycled paper. Fresh News says its paper is 100% post-consumer material and that the litter is biodegradable when composted. Check the product’s disposal directions and local composting rules before disposing of used litter that way.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is paper cat litter clumping?
Not necessarily. The paper products listed here are non-clumping pellets. Check the package description to confirm whether a specific formula clumps.
Which option in this list clumps?
Tuft & Paw Really Great is described as fast-clumping, but it is tofu-based rather than paper-based.
Which paper litter lists baking soda?
Both Fresh News Original sizes and Fresh News Multi-Cat list baking soda as part of their odor-control features.
Which listed paper litter does not add baking soda?
Small Pet Select says its odor blocker is all-natural and that no baking soda is added.
Is recycled paper litter flushable?
The listed paper litter descriptions do not claim that the products are flushable. Follow package disposal directions and local guidance.