The best small dog bully sticks are sized for a smaller mouth and chewing style. Natural Farm’s 4-inch sticks suit buyers who want a short beef chew, while Nature Gnaws’ extra-thin pork option offers a different protein. Jack&Pup and BRUTUS & BARNABY focus on skinny sticks, and Nature Gnaws’ beef option keeps the ingredient familiar for beef-chew buyers. Compare size, protein, and pack count, and supervise your dog during chewing.
| Product | Best For | Size And Count | Protein |
|---|---|---|---|
| Natural Farm | Shorter chew sessions | 4 inches, 10 count | Beef |
| Nature Gnaws Pork | Small dogs needing a thin chew | 5–6 inches, 15 count | Pork |
| Jack&Pup Skinny | Puppies and senior dogs | 6 inches, 30 pack | Beef |
| BRUTUS & BARNABY Skinny | Small or medium dogs | 6 inches, 16 count | Beef |
| Nature Gnaws Beef | Beef-protein preference | 5–6 inches, 10 count | Beef |
Natural Farm 4-Inch Bully Sticks
These 4-inch beef bully sticks are the shortest option in this group. Natural Farm says they are made with grass-fed beef, cleaned with water, and slow oven-baked at its food-grade facility. The brand describes the treats as grain-free, hormone-free, and chemical-free, with beef as the sole ingredient.
Best for: Small dogs and puppies whose owners prefer a shorter chew rather than a 5- or 6-inch stick. The compact length may also suit buyers who want to offer a brief chew session.
Limitation: The package contains 10 sticks, fewer than the 15- and 30-count options below. As with any chew, supervise your dog and remove pieces that become small enough to swallow.
Nature Gnaws Extra-Thin Pork Sticks
Nature Gnaws’ pork chews measure 5–6 inches and come in a 15-count pack. The company identifies pork pizzle as the single ingredient and describes the sticks as low-odor, grain-free, gluten-free, and rawhide-free. Chewing is also presented as a way to help reduce plaque and tartar buildup.
Best for: Owners looking for a thin chew made from pork instead of beef. The product is specifically described for small dogs, teething puppies, and senior chewers.
Limitation: This is a pork-based treat, so it may not fit a dog’s established diet or protein restrictions. Check with your veterinarian if you are unsure whether pork is appropriate.
Jack&Pup 6-Inch Skinny Bully Sticks
This 30-pack contains 6-inch skinny beef sticks. Jack&Pup describes them as single-ingredient beef pizzle with no additives or preservatives. The product is marketed as low-odor and rawhide-free, with a thinner shape intended to be easier to chew for small dogs, puppies, and senior dogs.
Best for: Buyers who want a larger pack of narrow beef chews. Compared with the shorter Natural Farm sticks, these are longer; compared with the 16-count BRUTUS & BARNABY pack, this option provides more sticks per package.
Limitation: The 6-inch length may be more than an owner wants for a very short chew session. Choose a size based on your dog’s chewing habits, not length alone.
BRUTUS & BARNABY Skinny Bully Sticks
These 6-inch skinny sticks come in a 16-count pack. The brand describes them as single-ingredient grass-fed South American beef pizzle, with no grain, fillers, artificial preservatives, or added hormones. It also says the sticks are air-dried to reduce odor and are intended for small dogs, puppies, and senior dogs.
Best for: Owners who want a narrow beef chew and prefer a 16-count pack rather than Jack&Pup’s 30-count package. The product’s listed use includes smaller mouths and gentler jaws.
Limitation: These are still 6 inches long, so they are not the shortest choice in this comparison. Check the individual stick before offering it and supervise chewing.
Nature Gnaws Extra-Thin Beef Sticks
Nature Gnaws’ extra-thin beef sticks are 5–6 inches long and come in a 10-count package. The brand lists beef pizzle as the single ingredient and describes the chews as low-odor, grain-free, gluten-free, and rawhide-free. It also presents chewing as support for reducing plaque and tartar.
Best for: Small-dog owners who want Nature Gnaws’ extra-thin format but prefer beef over the brand’s pork version. This is a straightforward alternative to the pork pack when beef is the desired protein.
Limitation: The package has fewer sticks than Nature Gnaws’ 15-count pork option. Compare pack count as well as protein when choosing between the two.
Buying Guide: How To Choose Bully Sticks For A Small Dog
What length and thickness should you choose?
Compare both length and thickness. The 4-inch Natural Farm sticks are shorter, while the other products range from 5–6 inches to 6 inches. Skinny or extra-thin descriptions indicate a narrower style, but the listings do not provide exact diameters. Choose a chew your dog can hold and manage comfortably, and avoid assuming that every stick labeled for small dogs suits every small dog.
Should you choose beef or pork?
Start with your dog’s usual diet and any known protein sensitivities. Four options here are beef-based, while Nature Gnaws’ 15-count product is pork-based. If your dog follows a restricted diet or has had food reactions, ask your veterinarian before introducing a new protein.
Does pack count matter?
Yes. The listed packages range from 10 to 30 sticks. A larger count may reduce how often you need to restock, but pack size does not tell you how long an individual chew will last. Chewing time varies by dog and by stick.
Are bully sticks a substitute for dental care?
No. These brands describe chewing as helping reduce plaque or tartar, but a chew should not replace veterinary dental advice or routine oral care. Ask your veterinarian about a dental-care plan for your dog.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are bully sticks suitable for puppies?
Several products are marketed for puppies, including the Natural Farm, Nature Gnaws, Jack&Pup, and BRUTUS & BARNABY options. Select a size appropriate for the puppy and supervise chewing.
Which option is shortest?
Natural Farm’s sticks are 4 inches long, making them the shortest listed option.
Which product has the largest pack?
Jack&Pup lists a 30-pack, the largest count among these five products.
Are all five products beef-based?
No. Four are beef-based. Nature Gnaws’ 15-count extra-thin option is made from pork pizzle.
How should I supervise my dog with a bully stick?
Watch your dog while chewing, inspect the stick during use, and take it away if it becomes small enough to swallow. Follow the product’s package directions.